This year’s Best Animated Feature Film race featured five nominees for just the second time in the category’s existence. It was the result of a robust slate of qualifying contenders that reached the magic number of 16, and yet there was still quality work left lying in the also-rans pile.
There was a wide open fifth slot throughout most of the season as a generally agreed-upon four slowly coagulated. Come nomination morning, the field therefore offered one of the many exciting surprises as a foreign independent project from a first-time filmmaker one-upped films both critically (“Ponyo”) and commercially (“Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs”) successful.
The nominees are:
“Coraline” (Henry Selick)
“Fantastic Mr. Fox” (Wes Anderson)
“The Princess and the Frog” (John Musker and Ron Clements)
“The Secret of Kells” (Tomm Moore)
“Up” (Pete Docter)
As the year winds down, and critics and entertainment journalists search for neat blanket tags with which to label the year that was, “the year of animation” is a phrase that is getting increasingly bandied about – some going so far as to 
“My God, they’ve thrown in everything but the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.”
One of the titles we mentioned a couple of weeks ago that could slide in and help rescue the animated feature category (as in, push the field of qualifying contenders closer to 16, which would yield the potential for five, rather than three nominees) was something called 
•
We’ve been hot on the animated feature trail as of late, keeping a keen eye on the number of films that have qualified, plan to qualify, or have opted out of qualifying, the magic number of 16 titles (which would warrant a five-nominee slate rather than three) being the key throughout.
Two weeks ago we told you about
•
Earlier today Tom O’Neil reported that 
•
Yesterday we