In Contention

Reel Geezers on ‘Precious’

Written by

in

I’m featuring this review for one reason: if anybody had concerns that the older white majority of the Academy would be resistant to “Precious” … well, worry no more. (The Geezers are on indieWIRE these days, by the way.)

Comments

9 responses to “Reel Geezers on ‘Precious’”

  1. Loyal Avatar

    I didnt know people felt that way. If anything, Precious is the anti-Do The Right Thing or Boyz n the Hood. It has absolutely nothing to say about the black experience and instead plays heavily on white guilt.

    It’s the safest whitest movie possibly made, featuring black people, created by black filmmakers. Once they attached Oprah to it, getting old white people on board became a no-brainer.

  2. Alex Avatar
    Alex

    Thanks for posting. I thought these guys died since I hadn’t heard from them in a while.

    BTW Variety and THR have their Invictus review up…..

  3. James D. Avatar

    They ARE alive!

  4. Chase H. Avatar
    Chase H.

    Loyal,

    Precious isn’t a film about the so called “black experience,” it’s a film about characters who happen to be black.

  5. Aleksis Avatar
    Aleksis

    lol “the black experience”.

    How come it mostly seems to be privileged white people who whine the loudest about films like Precious and Slumdog Millionaire being “racist” and “patronising”?

  6. /3rtfu11 Avatar
    /3rtfu11

    I’m fucking sick of the white guilt accusation. If you want white guilt, watch “Jackie Brown”.

    “Precious” was intended for black audiences. I don’t see it as art-house, or commercial.
    The fact that it made a breakthrough at Sundance means the indie crowd is tried of the same white bread, weirdo, pretentious, bullshit – which makes the best of list for the online set.

  7. Loyal Avatar

    Aleksis, not sure. I’m neither white nor privileged.

  8. Paul Outlaw Avatar
    Paul Outlaw

    “It’s the safest whitest movie possibly made, featuring black people, created by black filmmakers.”

    That’s funny. Almost as funny as movies by and featuring Tyler Perry and the Wayans Bros., speaking of safe.

  9. Andrew Avatar
    Andrew

    I’m so glad these two are back. They make my awards season.