Features







2007-08 Oscar Calendar



[Monday, December 3, 2007]

Official Screen Credits
Forms Due.


[Wednesday, December 26, 2007]

Nominations ballots mailed.


[Saturday, January 12, 2008]

Nominations polls close
5 p.m. PST.


[Tuesday, January 22, 2008]

Nominations announced
5:30 a.m. PST
Samuel Goldwyn Theater


[Wednesday, January 30, 2008]

Final ballots mailed.


[Monday, February 4, 2008]

Nominees Luncheon


[Saturday, February 9, 2008]

Scientific and Technical
Awards Dinner


[Tuesday, February 19, 2008]

Final polls close 5 p.m. PST.


[Sunday, February 24, 2008]

79th Annual
Academy Awards Presentation
Kodak Theatre

Powered by
Movable Type 3.2


« Clean-Up on Aisle Septemb… | Main | "TECH SUPPORT": Best Soun… »

"The Diving Bell and the Butterfly" (****)

diving1.jpg


“The Diving Bell and the Butterfly” is the result of uncommon cinematic vision, in this case springing from the mind of filmmaker Julian Schnabel. As divisive a persona as his techniques could be construed, Schnabel is a consummate artist striving for vastly different things behind the camera than any of his contemporaries. In his latest effort, the director has created a menagerie that becomes that rare example of a film less impressive in the sum of its parts than it is in the analysis of each working component. It is masterful in ways it seems critical analysis has not yet considered.

Matthieu Amalric stars as Jean-Dominque Bauby, the publisher of “Elle” magazine who suffered a sudden stroke in 1995 that rendered him paralyzed but for one eye. Left with little more than his memories and his imagination, Bauby capitalized on a lingering book deal he had signed with a publisher and set about writing an autobiography. The account was dictated via a system in which he would blink his eye to corresponding letters of the alphabet, ultimately telling his tale from the prison of an immovable body – his “diving bell.” He lived to see the book’s publication before passing away a mere ten days later.


A guy blinking his life story – only Julian Schnabel could find something cinematic about that. And indeed he does.


Much of “The Diving Bell and the Butterfly” is visually conveyed in a first person perspective that is equal parts claustrophobic and fascinating. While the effect instills a certain empathy in the viewer, it also allows for insight as Bauby’s thoughts are spoken by Amalric as if reverberating inside the character’s mind. It is also through this brazen panache that cinematographer Janusz Kaminski is given room to really experiment aside from his wonderful lighting in the more traditional sequences. I notice Gerard did not include Kaminski at all in his recent “Tech Support” column spotlighting the DPs of the season. That might prove a mistake as Kaminski’s work is essential to the artistry of the film.


diving2.jpg


Amalric is accompanied on screen by “Munich” co-star Marie-Josée Croze, as Henriette, one of Bauby’s nurses who concocts the dictation system. Emmanuelle Seigner is Céline, the mother of Bauby’s three children, and together with Croze, she offers a delicate feminine balance for Bauby’s internal, macho persona. But the real specter of delicacy is inherent in a two-scene performance by Max von Sydow as Bauby’s father, Papinou.


I don’t think I’ve seen a relationship so clearly and beautifully rendered in such a small amount of time in a long while. An initial encounter told in flashback with Bauby giving his father a shave – the last time he saw him before the stroke – provides deep context for a later encounter over the phone, during which Papinou can’t handle the pain of speaking to a son he knows cannot respond. “I miss you,” he tells Bauby, tears streaming down his eyes, sick with confusion. It’s one of the more powerful scenes of the year in the amount of emotion it generates, and given Amalric has little to do other than sit and stare at the telephone, the task is completely in Sydow’s hands. It could be affecting enough to generate a fair share of supporting actor votes come January.


With all this in mind, there is a living, beating heart beneath the surface of “The Diving Bell and the Butterfly” that Schnabel seems paradoxically intent on containing as much as possible. Any time the viewer feels the blissful serenade of the film’s various episodic segments and musical interludes, the director cuts sharply away and to the next chapter, so to speak, as if he is unwilling to cajole or, like so many of Bauby’s fantasies, allow himself to stray from what is his subject’s unflinching predicament. It’s a form of honesty one has to appreciate when the risk of pandering is so prevalent.


diving3.jpg


Regarding the awards season, I have to say that Miramax seems to be four-square behind this film in the Oscar department – good. There is no question that the studio’s other major hopeful, “No Country for Old Men,” is a cold and empty experience, regardless of artistic merit captured here and there that might appeal to this branch or that. “The Diving Bell and the Butterfly,” however, is a piece of work that actually does something with its unavoidable chill-factor. It’s a smart, precise piece of filmmaking that knows how to make the most of an entirely un-cinematic situation. It also generates a genuine emotional response that will surely resonate with anyone who fears unfinished business with their loved ones. And who doesn’t cower at the potential regret of tomorrow in the face of taking today for granted?

Comments

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Contact Us

Search


2008 Year in Advance Predictions


UPDATED: 2/25/2008





Main Charts | Tech Charts



[Motion Picture]

“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

“Doubt”

“Frost/Nixon”

“Revolutionary Road”

“The Soloist”



[Directing]

David Fincher
“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

Ron Howard
“Frost/Nixon”

Gus Van Sant
“Milk”

Sam Mendes
“Revolutionary Road”

Joe Wright
“The Soloist”



[Actor in a Leading Role]

Benicio Del Toro
“The Argentine”

Jamie Foxx
“The Soloist”

Frank Langella
“Frost/Nixon”

Sean Penn
“Milk”

Brad Pitt
“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”



[Actress in a Leading Role]

Vera Farmiga
“Nothing But the Truth”

Angelina Jolie
“Changeling”

Julianne Moore
“Blindness”

Meryl Streep
“Doubt”

Kate Winslet
“Revolutionary Road”



[Actor in a Supporting Role]

Josh Brolin
“Milk”

Russell Crowe
“Body of Lies”

Robert Downey, Jr.
“The Soloist”

Heath Ledger
“The Dark Knight”

Michael Sheen
“Frost/Nixon”



[Actress in a Supporting Role]

Amy Adams
“Doubt”

Kathy Bates
“Revolutionary Road”

Cate Blanchett
“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

Catherine Keener
“The Soloist”

Carice van Houten
“Body of Lies”



[Writing, Adapted Screenplay]

“Body of Lies”

“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

“Doubt”

“Frost/Nixon”

“Revolutionary Road”



[Writing, Original Screenplay]

“Changeling”

“Hamlet 2”

“Milk”

“The Soloist”

“WALL·E”



[Art Direction]

“Australia”

“Defiance”

“Indiana Jones and the Kingdom
of the Crystal Skull”

“Red Cliff”

“Revolutionary Road”



[Cinematography]

“Australia”

“The Dark Knight”

“Defiance”

“Indiana Jones and the Kingdom
of the Crystal Skull”

“Revolutionary Road”



[Costume Design]

“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

“Doubt”

“The Other Boleyn Girl”

“Red Cliff”

“Revolutionary Road”



[Film Editing]

“Body of Lies”

“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

“Defiance”

“Frost/Nixon”

“Indiana Jones and the Kingdom
of the Crystal Skull”



[Makeup]

“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

“The Dark Knight”

“Red Cliff”



[Music, Original Score]

“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”

“Indiana Jones and the Kingdom
of the Crystal Skull”

“The Soloist”

“Revolutionary Road”

“WALL·E”



[Music, Original Song]

coming soon



[Sound Editing]

“Defiance”

“Indiana Jones and the Kingdom
of the Crystal Skull”

“Iron Man”

“Speed Racer”

“WALL·E”



[Sound Mixing]

“Defiance”

“Indiana Jones and the Kingdom
of the Crystal Skull”

“Cloverfield”

“The Chronicles of Narnia:
Prince Caspian”

“WALL·E”



[Visual Effects]

“The Chronicles of Narnia:
Prince Caspian”

“The Incredible Hulk”

“Iron Man”



[Animated Feature Film]

“9”

“Kung Fu Panda”

“WALL·E”



[Foreign Language Film]

coming soon



[Documentary, Features]

coming soon



[Documentary, Short Subjects]

coming soon



[Short Film, Animated]

coming soon



[Short Film, Live Action]

coming soon