Best Music - Volume I

Can you even begin to imagine Steven Spielberg’s “Jaws” without John Williams’s chugging theme? I bet you can’t. Williams’s creation of a character – the shark – through music is just one example of how, when utilized creatively and to its full extent, original music can bring a film to a level it never would have reached otherwise.
The music branch in the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences gives out two awards each year – Best Original Score and Best Original Song. The former is one of the more high profile “tech” races on Oscar night. Precursor awards-dishing organizations like the BFCA and the HFPA give out awards for original score, and in recent years, the Academy has specifically showcased the five nominees for this award as they have done for directors and actors. I consider that a nice touch.
The category is nevertheless one of the most difficult to predict. Year after year, the branch seems to care little about what the precursors say. Nominees in the category tend to be an interesting mix of blockbusters, comedies, Best Picture nominees and serious-minded films not included in the Best Picture race.
The music branch earned a reputation between 1999 and 2003 of being very insular, with only two of the 25 Best Original Score nominations during going to new composers during that period. Yet in the last two years, the branch has welcomed five new competitors into the fold. But while this might be indicative of the branch opening up, the field in these past two years wasn’t exactly ultra-competitive.

One face that is almost always among the nominees is the aforementioned John Williams. He has not missed a nomination in a year in which he has been eligible since 1992. Alas, he is not in the running for any title this year, so that’s one shoo-in we can certifiably cross of the list.
The man who stopped Williams from achieving Oscar #6 last year – Gustavo Santaolalla – could make another appearance this year for Alejandro González Iñárritu’s “Babel.” His music for the film is beautiful and film serving. Paramount Vantage also deserves kudos for getting it out there (the soundtrack has been mailed out to various press and awards-voting bodies in the past few weeks). However, the score is also very minimalist and lacks an instantly iconic theme like the one that landed Santaolalla the nomination – and win – last year for “Brokeback Mountain.”
Classical composer Philip Glass ventured into cinematic efforts relatively late in his career. He managed an Oscar nomination for wonderful work on Martin Scorsese’s “Kundun” in 1997 (a year he was destined to lose to James Horner and the unstoppable “Titanic”). Glass probably came very close to the win for Stephen Daldry’s “The Hours” in 2002. But even with a wealth of exceptional work already behind him, Glass’s score for Richard Eyre’s “Notes on a Scandal” may very well be the crowning achievement of his career – loud at the right moments, eerily quiet at the appropriate times while ultimately memorable and haunting all the same. It is also the sort of score that the Academy loves to nominate. Glass also composed for Neil Burger’s “The Illusionist” this year, which may very well help his chances.
The person I expect to be Glass’s major competition for the win this season is Thomas Newman. With seven nominations to his credit over the past dozen years, Newman is clearly well respected by the branch. This year, he has composed a soaring, old-fashioned score for Steven Soderbergh’s “The Good German,” truly one of his most original compositions in years. This is exactly the sort of score the branch loves to recognize, regardless of a given film’s quality. It is worth mentioning that Newman also provided the effectively understated (if overly similar to “American Beauty”) compositions for Todd Field’s “Little Children.”

Glass and Newman are the two nominees I’m most confident in predicting. But thereafter things really open up.
Randy Newman, Thomas’s first cousin, finally won an Oscar in 2001, following a winless streak of 16 nominations, for “Monsters, Inc.” “Cars” is his most AMPAS-friendly effort since that film. It will be interesting to see if the branch is as fond of him as they were before he finally took home a statue.
Another branch favorite, James Horner, is reuniting with Mel Gibson this year on “Apocalypto.” This is the sort of effort that screams out as an opportunity for a musician to really show their talent. Gibson’s last two films have also received considerable love from the technical branches in the Academy. The path for Horner, who also composed “All the King’s Men” this year, seems like a clear one, pending “Apocalypto”’s critical fate, of course.
Horner had also originally been on board Robert De Niro’s “The Good Shepherd,” but the two have parted ways on the project. This has paved the way for Marcello Zavros to take over, who made some ripples in 2004 with specific work on Tod Williams’s “The Door in the Floor.” If De Niro’s film turns into a hit, there’s no telling what could happen to this talented young composer.
The person most are expecting to fill a “first-time nominee slot” is Alexandre Desplat. The great French composer ventured into American movies in recent years and has achieved much acclaim for “Girl With a Pearl Earring,” “Birth” and “Syriana”, among others. His delicate compositions in Stephen Frears’s Best Picture hopeful “The Queen” have already received considerable attention. Desplat is also composing John Curran’s “The Painted Veil,” which strikes me as the sort of vehicle more traditionally nominated. So which, if either, film will it be? Or might Desplat double-dip this season?

Alberto Iglesias finally earned his first nomination last year for his lively and ranging compositions in Fernardo Meirelles’s “The Constant Gardener.” He finds himself collaborating once again this year with the director who made him famous: Pedro Almodóvar. To be perfectly frank, I did not much care for Iglesias’s work on “Volver.” But I recognize that I seem to be in the minority on this front, and a nomination is certainly feasible. Exotic, foreign-sounding scores often find a home here.
Also in the world of foreign-language features is Shigeru Umbayashi, who again has composed the music for a Zhang Yimou feature: “Curse of the Golden Flower.” Sony Pictures Classics is poised to give this film a significant Oscar shove, and Umbayashi seems like the sort of talent who will be recognized eventually.
Craig Armstrong has had quite the run in the past few years for blending original score with famous songs, most notably on Baz Lurrhmann’s “Moulin Rouge!,” Richard Curtis’s “Love Actually” and Taylor Hackford‘s “Ray.” His themes in “World Trade Center” are poignantly used throughout the movie. It is admittedly rather short for an Original Score nod, but if they like the film, one never knows. Last year’s winner in this category had less than 20 minutes of original music. (EDITOR’S NOTE: And Mr. Armstrong showing up at Morton’s in Los Angeles a few months back amidst a “World Trade Center” event to play his works live on the piano is the sort of thing that stays in a person’s memory.)
Speaking of 9/11 films, the prolific John Powell (who has marked 26 films to his credit since 2001) gracefully blended music into Paul Greengrass’s “United 93” this year. However, this is not really the sort of score that the Academy tends to nominate. Powell also did “Happy Feet” this year, though that score might be deemed ineligible due to too many songs filling out the soundtrack.

Speaking of animated efforts, Douglas Pipes provided fantastic compositions this year for “Monster House.” The music was scary, joyous and fun. But the film didn’t really catch to the degree necessary to make nominations beyond Animated Feature likely.
Hans Zimmer has 7 nominations and one win to his credit. He’s really struggled with getting Academy love this decade, however. His original work in Ron Howard’s “The Da Vinci Code” was highlighted quite clearly in the film, and Columbia Pictures is placing ads strictly for him. While the music branch is not necessarily opposed to nominating critically maligned films, I’m doubtful that this is the feature to bring Zimmer back into the fold.
Speaking of critically maligned films getting Oscar nominations, James Newton Howard managed a nod here two years ago for “The Village.” But I can’t see him pulling that trick again for “Lady in the Water,” with “Blood Diamond” probably marginally more likely – but the fumes seem to be rising off of that one, given the hints here and there. (EDITOR’S NOTE: *sniff* *sniff*)
I’ll end the original score discussion by mentioning a very famous person, but one whose claim to fame is certainly not music – Clint Eastwood. After composing the main theme to “Unforgiven” 14 years ago, Eastwood has increasingly risen to the task of crafting the music for his films. “Flags of Our Fathers” and “Letters from Iwo Jima” mark the fourth and fifth films for which he has composed the score this decade, and though similar to his past work, the music is nonetheless memorable. Paramount Pictures has already placed a full-page “for your consideration” ad for the “Flags” score. So if the Academy likes these films, one never knows where that will take their Oscar tally.

Best Original Song is a category where the manner of choosing nominees changed last year. A list of contenders will be announced beforehand, and the branch will then grade them, with a minimum grade being necessary for a nomination. If less than five films achieve the necessary score to be nominated, then there will only be three or four nominees (as happened last year).
A film that is not eligible in score may try to dominate this category. Henry Krieger has co-written three original songs for the film adaptation of his stage play “Dreamgirls.” While “Patience” and “Love You I Do” could sneak nods, it’s ultimately “Listen” which seems most likely to get a nomination with ease – and contend for the win. Beyoncé Knowles, who also co-wrote the song, is at her best when singing ballads, in my opinion, and this one seems to be everything the Academy loves to award.
Another film with multiple original songs is “A Prairie Home Companion,” the appropriate swansong to the career of director Robert Altman. “Bad Jokes” and “Goodbye to My Mama” may not be the sort of ditties that traditionally garner Oscar nominations, but Picturehouse Films is kicking up the Oscar campaign for this sweet and nostalgic film nonetheless.
“A Father’s Way” from “The Pursuit of Happyness,” performed by Seal over the closing credits, will also try to garner traction in this year’s race. I haven’t heard the song, so I can’t comment on its quality. But Columbia Pictures has big plans for the film (with a Lead Actor nod looking like a good bet for Will Smith). A tag-along nomination for a song certainly wouldn’t seem out of the question, but will the usage of the song over credits be deemed less film serving than other tunes in play?

Chris Cornell contributed the latest title song in the James Bond series with “You Know My Name.” I did not care for the song, but my opinion is hardly Gospel on these matters. “Casino Royale” was, without a doubt, the best Bond movie in a very long time, so some Oscar recognition would be nice. But title James Bond tracks have tended to miss the boat in recent years.
Emilio Estevez’s “Bobby” may have taken a critical beating of sorts so far, but I really don’t think that will have much of an affect on the chances of Bryan Adams’s “Never Gonna Break My Faith,” sung from the gut by Aretha Franklin and Mary J. Bilge. Adams is a three-time nominee, after all. Plus, one can be sure The Weinstein Company will defiantly push all corners of this project toward Oscar glory.
Animated features are frequent nominees here. If the branch doesn’t find a home for him in score, Randy Newman could easily garner a nod for “Our Town,” performed in “Cars” by Americana favorite James Taylor. It’s the sort of sweet lament I suspect the branch will love. Meanwhile, Prince will try to follow up his Oscar win 22 years ago for “Purple Rain” with a Best Original Song citation in “Happy Feet,” for “Song of the Heart.” Both Newman and Prince certainly have the profile to garner nominations, and everyone loves to see them perform.
In the realm of children’s films, we also have “Ordinary Miracle” from “Charlotte’s Web” by the very well known David A. Stewart and Oscar-nominee Glen Ballard (“The Polar Express”). This is certainly a title that should be considered.

Sheryl Crow definitely possesses high profile in spades, and she has also contributed a song to the movies this year, “Try Not to Remember” from Irwin Winkler’s “Home of the Brave.” However, Winkler’s directorial filmography is not exactly awe-inspiring, and I don’t expect this film to break that trend (EDITOR’S NOTE: It doesn’t.). So Crow’s tune might have an uphill battle here.
I’ll finish with a genre of films that have never traditionally found a home in the Best Original Song category, but will seriously contend here this year for sure – documentaries.
“Shut Up and Sing” hasn’t really caught on to the degree that might have been necessary to get awards traction outside of its staple Best Documentary Feature category. But the Dixie Chicks have the profile that might be good enough to get their song “The Neighbor” into contention.
“An Inconvenient Truth,” on the other hand, did very well indeed at the box office for a documentary effort. This is not to mention the fact that it’s one of the best-reviewed films of the year, and is likely to return to a lot of people’s lips come year-end top ten lists. Melissa Etheridge’s “I Need to Wake Up” is also a fantastic and film-serving song. Moreover, Paramount Vantage is making sure the track makes the rounds to press and voting bodies. So if Etheridge can’t get nominated, it might be indication of the true ghettoization of documentaries to their own category.
So that completes a lengthy first glance at all technical categories. Next week, we’ll shake things up a little (as precursors are already beginning to fall).



















