TECH SUPPORT: Best Sound Editing — Volume I

Posted by · 11:31 am · August 26th, 2010

Now matter how many times I watch the Oscars, someone will always ask, “So what is the difference between the two sound categories?”

The difference is quite significant.  It is so important that the sound branch is only one of two “tech” branches in the Academy (the other being music) that gives out two separate awards.  Best Sound Mixing awards the individuals who bring the entire soundscape – music, dialogue, effects – together into a balanced mix.

Best Sound Editing, on the other hand (perhaps better described by its previous name, Best Sound Effects Editing), rewards the artificial creation of sounds to be inserted into the film, but were not captured during the shoot.

The category, despite its very specific nature, is nevertheless like many other “tech” categories.  Both “loud” films (often war films) and blockbusters are among this category’s favorite fetishes.  And like virtually all categories, being a Best Picture contender can be a big help.

The category is also notable for its embracing of animated titles.  This is not altogether surprising as all non-dialogue sounds in such movies need to be created artificially, though it’s a more recent trend. This is one area where Best Sound Editing can truly be distinguished from Best Sound Mixing.

So what should we expect this year?  Well, I’d certainly expect Christopher Nolan’s “Inception” to be among the nominees.  Richard King won this category for “The Dark Knight” in 2008, becoming the only individual to defeat “Slumdog Millionaire” in any category.  The reviews for Nolan’s film, status as a prestigious blockbuster and noticeable soundscape all suggest to me that another nomination for King is quite likely.

King is also collaborating once again with Peter Weir this year on “The Way Back.” While King’s second Oscar came for a Nolan film, he won his first statuette for a Weir film: 2003’s “Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World.” As I’ve stated before, lacking a U.S. distributor in late August is troubling.  But I’d never rule a Weir film out.  And King may just have a fair bit to work with here.

In the realm of the summer blockbuster, I’d also look to “Iron Man 2.” The film’s predecessor was nominated here (though notably not in Best Sound Mixing) and the follow-up, while not as critically adored, featured sound effects every bit as impressive, and a fantastic box office to boot.  Frank E. Eulner and Christopher Boyes may well repeat the nomination they shared two years ago.

While “Inception” and “Iron Man 2” seem the most likely of the live action summer blockbusters to end up with a nomination, I wouldn’t rule out others, such as “Salt” and “Robin Hood,” either of which could make a run for it.  Both films featured the sort of work this category frequently embraces.  While the “Salt” crew hasn’t seen Oscar success yet, “Robin Hood” has perennial favorite Wylie Stateman on board.

So what of the blockbusters to come?  I’d certainly look to “TRON Legacy,” where sound effects will undoubtedly be pivotal in building not only the action scenes but also the plot and the characters.  I’m not sure who the sound editor will be but the opportunity will surely be a great one.

“Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1” is also floating around.  I’m actually surprised the series has never managed a nomination here (even moreso than for the mixing).  But if any title was going to be nominated here from this series, I think it would be the last one.

There are also more adult-oriented entries that are still on their way.  The Coen brothers’ “True Grit” will have to create the sounds of the old West, which will surely involve the genre staple: gunfights.  One never knows how remakes will play (nor do I know who the supervising sound editors are), but this is a great opportunity.

Horse races are also fantastic opportunities for cinematic sound artists.  As such, keeping track of Disney’s “Secretariat” seems wise.  Kami Asgar and Sean McCormack were previously nominated for another unlikely effort, “Apocalypto,” and they could yet repeat the accomplishment.

To return to one of this category’s favorite genres, we must not forget the animation on display this year.   And in the realm of Best Picture likelihood and box office prestige, “Toy Story 3” is clearly leading the way.  Tom Myers and Michael Silvers have accumulated seven nominations in as many years and a win strictly from Pixar efforts.  This seems quite likely to be number eight.

I’ll end by mentioning the animated film that, due to its subject matter, would appear most likely to join the toys.  “How to Train Your Dragon” contains many artificial noises that feature prominently.  The great Randy Thom is heading up this sound crew, which has to increase the likelihood of a nomination.

I don’t think the landscape in this category will change all that much between now and when the unseen contenders start unfolding in the next few months, but I’m sure some new titles will emerge in the race.  Next week, we look at the sister category – Best Sound Mixing.

[Photos: Paramount Pictures, Universal Pictures, DreamWorks Animation]




→ 9 Comments Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Filed in: Tech Support

9 responses so far

  • 1 8-26-2010 at 11:52 am

    Kristopher Tapley said...

    I expect Robin Hood to be in my predix for this category in Monday’s update. The sound stuck out to me when I saw the film and, as you say, Wylie is a favorite.

  • 2 8-26-2010 at 12:07 pm

    Bernard said...

    I think there’s one movie missing from consideration here with some phenomenal sound editing work: Scott Pilgrim vs. the World. More than any other movie I’ve seen this year, Scott Pilgrim’s sound work is a noticeable contribution. Granted, the use of sound editing is unconventional which may hurt it with some voters, but the creativity and skill of the work merits consideration.

    I also think early year films Shutter Island and (cringe) Clash of the Titans have some impressive sound editing work.

  • 3 8-26-2010 at 12:13 pm

    The Filmatelist said...

    If you’re right about “Secretariat” getting a nod, then I have two magic words for you: SCOTT GLENN.

    His films have won this category 4 times (w/only 1 loss–how’s *that* for obscure trivia?

  • 4 8-26-2010 at 12:46 pm

    Speaking English said...

    “Scott Pilgrim vs. the World” – what film this year more relies on the creation and implementation of artificial sound effects? Might as well give it the damn win!

  • 5 8-26-2010 at 1:47 pm

    Robert said...

    Ah, Bernard stole the words from my mouth! Scott Pilgrim definitely deserves some consideration in the sound categories – so many layers and tiny little details that made the movie just that much better. I really hope it gets its deserved recognition.

  • 6 8-26-2010 at 4:33 pm

    Red said...

    Is there any chance The Town is pulled in these two races? There seems to be plenty of gun fights, and from the way the trailer sounded they did a pretty good job with the sound of the weapons.

  • 7 8-26-2010 at 8:20 pm

    Glenn said...

    The distinction between the two sound categories seems so obvious that it’s funny some people have such a difficult time telling the two apart. Editing is the creation of sound, Mixing is how you hear it.

    Scott Pilgrim does deserve consideration, for sure, especially in the editing side of sound.

    What about “The Fighter”? Don’t boxing movies usually do well here?

  • 8 8-26-2010 at 8:21 pm

    John said...

    some stuff that deserves consideration, even if they’ll never let it in…

    THE CRAZIES, for which someone managed to create some scary-as-hell pitchfirk-stabs, whirring drills, etc.

    GREEN ZONE, which took us into the heart of the Iraq War with its sound effects (just not its script)

    CLASH OF THE TITANS, had plenty of mayhem and monsters, but this is largely for the Medusa sequence

    SPLICE, because for believably creating the sound of a mutant alien orgasm

  • 9 8-30-2010 at 1:04 pm

    Filmatelist said...

    GLENN: “What about “The Fighter”? Don’t boxing movies usually do well here?”

    Film Editing? Yes. Sound Editing? No, not a single boxing movie has ever received a nomination in this category. The only sports movies to win here are “Grand Prix” and “The Black Stallion”.